Ensuring Bitcoin Fungibility in 2017 (And Beyond)
Ensuring Bitcoin Fungibility in 2017 (And Beyond)
David Vorick is a Bitcoin Core developer, former IBM software developer and the co-founder of decentralized cloud storage platform Sia.
In the CoinDesk 2016 in Review special feature, Vorick tells us why ensuring fungibility remains a top priority for bitcoin developers entering 2017, and how 2016 increased awareness of what he argues is a pivotal issue.
Fungibility, put simply, is the idea that every item in a set is worth exactly the same amount.
In bitcoin, fungibility means that all bitcoins have the same value, regardless of who owns them or what their history is – and fungibility is extremely important to the success of a decentralized network.
To understand why, we have to analyze how bitcoin’s current limited fungibility is creating real problems in the marketplace.
For example, it’s common for exchanges and merchants to discriminate between bitcoins based on the owner or their history. An example is that exchanges will attempt to block bitcoins that have been stolen, especially if the theft was well publicized.
Other points of discrimination can extend to include bitcoins associated with drugs, gambling and other societal vices. But it’s important to note, this can happen even in cases where the owner of those bitcoins hasn’t engaged in any such behavior.
In short, the problem can be summed up like this: bitcoins with clean history can be accepted everywhere, while coins with dirty history can only be accepted in places that aren’t performing strict background checks.
Fair trade?
The problem is not that the merchants are rejecting bitcoins associated with unfavorable activities, the problem is the effect that it has on everyone else.
When performing a trade, dirty bitcoins are less valuable than clean coins. That means that everyone needs to know when they make a trade whether the bitcoins they will be receiving are dirty or clean, because that impacts whether they are getting a fair trade and whether they will be able to spend them or cash them out through the typical avenues.
The only way to know that your bitcoins are clean is to go to a centralized service and ask for a background check. Suddenly the value of your coins is being decided by a centralized party (something that many would argue runs directly against the core values of the bitcoin project).
Every platform accepting bitcoin could implement different policies for deciding which coins are clean or dirty. And exchanges in different legal jurisdictions (US, China, India, etc) are likely to have different policies.
The bitcoins worth the most money would then be the bitcoins accepted everywhere (which would only be a small subset of available bitcoins).
This means it’s not enough to just ask one exchange for a background check, you have to ask every major platform whether or not they think you have clean coins. And a platform doesn’t think that you have clean coins, their decision reduces the value of your holdings regardless of whether you actually use that platform – your coins cannot be traded with any of the platform’s users.
Worsening situation
2016 has increasingly seen bitcoin fungibility come under attack.
Blockchain forensics startup Elliptic was able to raise $5m for the purposes of identifying illicit bitcoins, while exchanges like Coinbase have become increasingly strict about accepting coins with known fringe histories.
So fungibility has been damaged, though not yet enough that people feel like they need to consult blacklist services before accepting bitcoins.
That day is getting closer, though, and when it arrives it will be a massive blow to the whole bitcoin ecosystem – the need to consult a blacklist service is the need to ask permission to use bitcoin.
It will mean that bitcoin has become centralized.
Because any platform in any jurisdiction can damage fungibility by choosing to discriminate between coins, most fungibility improvements come down to privacy. The best way to protect fungibility is to ensure that there’s no way to tell the difference between two coins, regardless of the actual history of those coins.
Solutions
2016 has seen a lot of momentum in this direction, with many of the improvements on track to become available to the general public in 2017.
Below is a list of the most exciting things happening with regards to fungibility.
Lightning Network
Most transactions today in bitcoin go onto the permanent public ledger, available for anyone to scrutinize.
Lightning changes this equation by allowing strangers who have never met to transact without ever making a transaction on the ledger – instead doing everything off-chain through the Lightning Network.
The number of open-source Lightning implementations increased substantially in 2016, with the total number now somewhere between five and 10. This list includes implementations from Lightning, Blockstream and MIT.
Though no solution is yet ready for the masses, there has been major progress, and several implementations are promising basic releases in 2017.
Most of the existing code depends on Segregated Witness (SegWit) activation, however. Provided SegWit succeeds, 2017 should be the year that you are able to try out bitcoin’s Lightning Network for yourself.
TumbleBit
A research paper for a new tumbling service was released in early 2016, TumbleBit is unlike existing tumbling services.
This was a big leap forward, as it provided tumbling service that could not scam its users, and also could not de-anonymize its users. In short, a major improvement to existing tumbling strategies.
More than just a paper, successful tumbling operations have been submitted over the live bitcoin network.
TumbleBit is not something that you can use today, however, but a command line release is expected in early 2017 and a user-friendly graphical release is expected mid year.
You can expect 2017 to be the first year where bitcoin can fully support large scale, anonymous, secure tumbling operations, and that’s exciting.
Zcash
Long awaited, October 2016 finally saw the release of Zcash, a cryptocurrency in pursuit of the holy grail of fungibility.
zkSnarks, the technology behind Zcash, make it possible to achieve true fungibility, where every single coin looks identical to every other coin. The issue is that only recent computers are powerful enough to perform Zcash transactions, and there is uncertainty that the cryptography will hold up against further scrutiny.
Still, 2017 is likely to see improved performance, reduced computational requirements, and quite possibly improvements to the cryptographic protocols.
The progress that Zcash has made so far is a huge benefit to the cryptocurrency ecosystem.
Monero
Monero is a cryptocurrency with a core focus of fungibility, and its greatest strength is perhaps its philosophy, which holds that fungibility is strongest when everybody is forced to use private transactions.
Monero essentially acts as a giant on-chain coin mixer, with every single transaction participating in the mixing. This has a huge advantage over traditional mixers, as people tend to only mix their coins when they have something to hide (meaning that it’s often reasonable to assume that coins are dirty merely because they’ve been mixed).
With Monero, that assumption is invalid, because all transactions contain mixed coins. Due to this philosophy, and due to the large number of users, Monero is perhaps the most fungibile cryptocurrency in the ecosystem, outperforming even Zcash by this attribute.
2016 saw a huge rise in popularity for Monero (placing it as the most valuable privacy-focused cryptocurrency), and saw the creation of a new protocol, RingCT, which combines Monero’s traditional output mixing with the ability to disguise the value of the coins being spent.
A hard fork in early 2017 will introduce RingCT into Monero, further enhancing the privacy and fungibility of the cryptocurrency.
Coming soon
Elsewhere, 2016 has seen massive progress in the direction of privacy and fungibility.
JoinMarket, which has been under active development by multiple developers throughout 2016, is working to provide a decentralized tumbling service. Further, 2016 saw the introduction of the MimbleWimble protocol, which would allow historic transactions to be removed entirely from the blockchain.
Progress was also made on privacy-improving technologies like MAST and Schnorr signature aggregation.
It’s believed Schnorr signature aggregation will allow multiparty signatures to appear like single-party signatures, while MAST will allow highly complicated scripts to appear like less-complicated scripts.
Client-side validation is an off-chain scaling technique which improves both privacy and scalability, allowing both the blockchain history and the blockchain state to be pruned, exposing tiny pieces only to those who need to see them.
Each of these improvements is good for fungibility, and each is being actively researched or developed.
With this in mind, it’s safe to say that fungibility research is very active today, and is likely to produce exciting new technologies in 2017.
Article Source: http://www.coindesk.com
Related Posts
China’s ‘First Web-Only Insurer’ Launches Blockchain Research Efforts
A web-based insurance firm in China is investing in new blockchain product development, with an eye to build a services …
Hyperledger Blockchain Project Adds 10 New Members
The Hyperledger blockchain project just got a little bit bigger. The Linux Foundation-backed consortium has announced 10 new members, of …
Bitcoin Developers Publish BIP For ‘Dandelion’ Privacy Project
Researchers looking to beef up bitcoin’s privacy features have released a new proposal on GitHub. Dubbed ‘Dandelion’, the project has …
Korean Credit Card Giant to Integrate Blockchain Identity Service
South Korea’s largest credit card company is set to use a blockchain identity solution developed by local bitcoin startup Coinplug. …
Features
-
62 Insane Facts About Bitcoin – Infographic Updated October 2017
-
Silicon Blockchain: Intel’s Distributed Ledger Strategy Is All About Hardware
-
Bitcoin’s Battle Over Segwit2x Has Begun
-
A Bitcoin Law for Every State? Interest and Animosity Greet Model US Regulation
-
The New Pachinko? Exploring the Economics of Initial Coin Offerings
I want to get across my admiration for your kindness supporting folks that need help with this important concern. Your special commitment to passing the solution all-around was really effective and has helped others like me to arrive at their aims. Your new warm and helpful guidelines denotes a great deal to me and still more to my colleagues. Thank you; from all of us.
I needed to draft you a little bit of remark just to thank you again on the gorgeous thoughts you have discussed in this case. This has been certainly particularly open-handed with you to allow publicly all that a number of people would’ve made available as an ebook to end up making some money for themselves, and in particular since you might have tried it if you wanted. Those guidelines likewise acted as the fantastic way to recognize that someone else have similar dreams much like my own to see more and more in terms of this matter. I am certain there are lots of more pleasant situations up front for those who start reading your website.
My husband and i got absolutely joyful that Albert could deal with his investigations via the ideas he acquired while using the web page. It’s not at all simplistic to just find yourself giving away key points some others could have been trying to sell. And we also already know we have the writer to appreciate for that. All the illustrations you made, the simple website menu, the relationships your site help to foster – it’s got many superb, and it’s really leading our son in addition to the family consider that the idea is fun, which is rather indispensable. Thank you for all the pieces!
I actually wanted to write down a small word to be able to say thanks to you for all of the awesome instructions you are sharing at this site. My extended internet investigation has finally been recognized with reasonable knowledge to write about with my guests. I would point out that we visitors are rather endowed to exist in a very good place with so many special individuals with interesting points. I feel rather privileged to have come across the weblog and look forward to some more enjoyable moments reading here. Thanks a lot once again for all the details.
I have to express my appreciation to this writer just for rescuing me from such a incident. As a result of researching through the the net and finding concepts that were not beneficial, I figured my life was well over. Living without the approaches to the problems you’ve fixed by way of your good article content is a serious case, as well as the ones that could have badly affected my entire career if I hadn’t come across your web blog. Your primary skills and kindness in maneuvering the whole lot was valuable. I am not sure what I would have done if I hadn’t encountered such a subject like this. I’m able to at this moment relish my future. Thanks a lot so much for the expert and amazing guide. I won’t be reluctant to suggest your site to anybody who needs to have direction on this subject matter.
I in addition to my pals were found to be viewing the great points found on your web page and quickly I had an awful suspicion I never expressed respect to the site owner for those tips. All of the boys are actually for that reason very interested to learn them and now have unquestionably been using them. Thank you for being considerably thoughtful and then for getting this form of incredibly good resources millions of individuals are really desperate to learn about. Our sincere regret for not expressing gratitude to sooner.
I抎 need to verify with you here. Which is not something I often do! I enjoy studying a put up that may make folks think. Also, thanks for permitting me to comment!
I would like to express some thanks to this writer just for rescuing me from this circumstance. As a result of researching throughout the the web and getting thoughts which are not pleasant, I thought my entire life was well over. Being alive without the presence of answers to the difficulties you’ve resolved as a result of your main article is a critical case, and the kind which could have negatively affected my entire career if I had not noticed your web site. Your actual skills and kindness in controlling all areas was vital. I am not sure what I would’ve done if I had not encountered such a step like this. It’s possible to now relish my future. Thank you very much for this reliable and results-oriented help. I will not be reluctant to refer your blog to any person who will need care on this topic.
I am also writing to let you understand of the really good encounter my cousin’s princess experienced reading through your web page. She learned a good number of details, which included how it is like to possess a great teaching mood to get the mediocre ones without hassle learn a variety of extremely tough things. You really did more than readers’ expected results. I appreciate you for producing those great, dependable, explanatory and even unique tips on your topic to Emily.
I would like to get across my love for your generosity in support of men and women that need assistance with your matter. Your personal commitment to passing the solution across came to be remarkably useful and have frequently empowered professionals just like me to reach their endeavors. Your own interesting publication means much to me and further more to my colleagues. Regards; from everyone of us.
My wife and i felt so cheerful when Ervin managed to carry out his investigation from your precious recommendations he received while using the blog. It’s not at all simplistic to just be giving away things people today have been selling. And we also fully grasp we have the website owner to be grateful to for this. All of the explanations you have made, the easy blog navigation, the relationships your site give support to promote – it’s many sensational, and it’s really letting our son and us reckon that this theme is thrilling, which is certainly pretty mandatory. Thanks for all the pieces!
I not to mention my friends ended up checking out the great hints from the website and then the sudden got a terrible suspicion I had not expressed respect to you for them. Most of the guys were absolutely warmed to learn all of them and already have sincerely been loving them. Thanks for genuinely so thoughtful and for settling on this sort of helpful areas millions of individuals are really wanting to be aware of. My personal sincere apologies for not expressing appreciation to sooner.
I am also commenting to make you understand of the fabulous encounter our girl experienced browsing your blog. She came to find plenty of pieces, with the inclusion of what it is like to possess an ideal teaching style to have other individuals effortlessly learn about a variety of specialized subject matter. You undoubtedly did more than visitors’ expectations. Thanks for presenting those essential, trustworthy, educational as well as fun tips about the topic to Lizeth.
I simply needed to thank you so much all over again. I’m not certain the things I might have taken care of without the information discussed by you over this subject. It actually was the troublesome crisis in my opinion, but being able to see this skilled strategy you dealt with it forced me to jump for joy. I am just happier for the advice as well as hope you really know what a powerful job you’re getting into training people today by way of your webpage. Most probably you haven’t got to know any of us.
Thanks a lot for providing individuals with an extraordinarily splendid possiblity to read from this web site. It is often so pleasurable plus jam-packed with amusement for me personally and my office peers to search your site nearly 3 times in 7 days to study the fresh tips you have got. And definitely, I’m so certainly astounded for the beautiful techniques you serve. Selected 4 tips in this post are completely the most beneficial I have had.
I intended to put you that tiny observation just to thank you very much over again considering the fantastic thoughts you’ve shared on this website. This has been extremely generous with you to offer publicly all many individuals would’ve made available as an e-book to generate some bucks for their own end, particularly seeing that you might have done it if you wanted. These guidelines in addition served to become a fantastic way to comprehend some people have a similar desire much like my very own to know the truth way more in terms of this issue. I believe there are many more enjoyable sessions in the future for individuals who look over your site.